CRO keyword cannibalization: why it matters and how to avoid it

Uncover the hidden challenges of keyword overlaps in SEO, their impact on conversion rates, and the roadmap to a streamlined, cannibalization-free site.

Hey there! Ever wondered why your well-optimized pages aren't showing up in search results the way you hoped? Maybe you've heard whispers about keyword cannibalization and how it might be affecting your site's performance. Well, today we're diving deep into what keyword cannibalization is and why it's crucial in the world of Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO). Grab a cuppa, and let's dive in!

Understanding keyword cannibalization

Imagine having two very similar ice cream flavors in a store. Both are, say, variants of chocolate. While one is chocolate fudge, the other is chocolate brownie. Customers might get confused about which one to choose. Similarly, keyword cannibalization happens when two or more pages on your website compete for the same keyword. Instead of helping you rank better, they end up eating into each other's chances (pun intended).

It's like those two ice cream flavors fighting for the spotlight!

Still with me? Great!

The impact of keyword cannibalization on CRO

You might think, More pages targeting the same keyword means more visibility, right? Well, not exactly. When pages cannibalize each other's keywords, search engines get confused. They're unsure which page is more relevant, leading to potential drops in ranking for both.

But it's not just about search engines. Think about your users. If they find multiple pages with almost similar content, they might get baffled and question the credibility of your website. And, when trust goes down, can you guess what happens to conversions? Yep, they plummet.

Common causes of keyword cannibalization

So how does this sneaky problem creep into our websites? Here are a few culprits:

  1. Multiple landing pages for a similar topic: Maybe you created multiple articles on how to choose running shoes over the years. While each might have unique info, they might still compete for the same keyword.
  2. Over-optimization: Enthusiasm's great, but sometimes we get too enthusiastic and stuff our content with the same keywords repeatedly.
  3. Diverse content types: You might have a blog post, a product page, and a video all optimized for the same keyword. While variety is the spice of life, in this case, it might just be adding to the confusion.

Can you think of times when you might have accidentally caused keyword cannibalization on your site? It's okay; we've all been there.

Identifying keyword cannibalization on your website

Now, before we panic, let's figure out if keyword cannibalization is happening on your site. Here are some tools and tricks:

  • Google Search Console: This tool can show you if multiple pages are ranking for the same keyword.
  • Screaming Frog or Ahrefs: These tools can give you insights into your website's SEO performance and highlight potential overlaps.
  • The manual check: Go to Google and type in your targeted keyword. If multiple pages pop up, you might have a problem.

Had any aha! moments yet?

Steps to resolve and avoid keyword cannibalization

Alright, let's get to the good stuff – fixing the issue! Here's a game plan:

  1. Consolidate content: If two blog posts are competing, why not merge them? Create one epic, comprehensive post and redirect the old ones to the new.
  2. De-optimize certain pages: If a page isn't crucial for a particular keyword, consider toning down the keyword usage on that page.
  3. Use canonical tags: Tell search engines which version of the content you'd prefer to rank. It's like politely saying, Hey, this one's the main attraction.
  4. Strategic internal linking: Link from the lesser important page to the more critical page, showing search engines which one they should prioritize.
  5. Regular content audits: Stay on top of your content game by regularly checking for overlaps and adjusting your strategy.

Sounds doable, right?

Enhancing CRO post-cannibalization cleanup

Once you've cleaned up the mess, it's time to boost that CRO! With clearer, non-competing content, users will find it easier to navigate your site and trust your expertise. The user journey becomes smoother, leading to higher chances of conversion. It's like clearing up a traffic jam and letting cars zoom smoothly down the highway. Feel the breeze yet?


CRO and keyword cannibalization are like two sides of the same coin. By ensuring our content isn't competing against itself, we pave the way for better user experience and, ultimately, higher conversions. Remember the ice cream analogy? Let's make sure each flavor (or page) shines on its own!

Facing similar issues? Need some expert guidance on streamlining your content and boosting conversions? That's where I come in. Reach out, and let's chat about how we can make your website shine even brighter. After all, who doesn't like a smooth-running website with sky-high conversions?

Supplemental tips for maintaining a cannibalization-free site

Ever felt the joy of a well-organized closet? Where everything has its place and you can easily grab what you need? That's what a website free from keyword cannibalization feels like. Streamlined, efficient, and user-friendly. Let's keep it that way! Here are some additional tips to ensure your site remains in tip-top shape.

Diversify your keyword strategy

Don't put all your eggs in one basket! By targeting a range of keywords, both head terms and long-tail variations, you give your content room to breathe and shine in its own right. Think about it: instead of ten articles on best running shoes, why not explore best running shoes for marathons or running shoes for wide feet? The sky's the limit!

Embrace topic clusters

Ever heard of the hub-and-spoke model? Picture a bike wheel. In the center, you've got the hub (a pillar page on a broad topic, like Running Essentials), and radiating out from it are the spokes (related, more specific content pieces). This model ensures your content is interconnected but not overlapping. It's a win-win!

Stay updated with industry trends

The digital landscape is ever-evolving. A keyword that's relevant today might be outdated tomorrow. By keeping a finger on the pulse of industry trends and shifts, you ensure your content remains fresh and relevant. Plus, who knows? You might discover a goldmine of a keyword no one's tapped into yet!

Engage with your audience

Feedback is a treasure trove. Engage with your readers through comments, emails, or even surveys. Understand what they're looking for, what questions they have, and then tailor your content to meet those needs. Not only does this reduce the risk of cannibalization, but it also builds a loyal community around your brand.

Regularly prune and refresh your content

Gone are the days when the more content you had, the better. Today, it's about quality over quantity. Set aside time to regularly review and prune outdated or underperforming content. Refresh old pieces with new insights or merge them if they're too similar. Your readers (and search engines) will thank you!

The bigger picture: Quality over quantity

In our race to rank higher and attract more traffic, it's easy to lose sight of what truly matters: providing value. Instead of churning out content piece after piece, focus on creating high-quality, unique articles that genuinely help your readers. After all, what's the point of attracting a million visitors if none of them find what they're looking for?

Optimizing for the future: The evolving landscape of CRO and SEO

So, we've covered the basics of keyword cannibalization, its impact on CRO, and how to tackle it. But in the fast-paced world of digital marketing, resting on our laurels isn't an option. The landscape is always shifting, and as savvy marketers, we need to stay ahead of the curve. Let's dive into some emerging trends and how we can adapt our strategies accordingly.

Voice search and conversational queries

Hey Siri, find me the best vegan pasta recipes. Sounds familiar? With the rise of smart speakers and virtual assistants, voice search is becoming a game-changer. This means our content needs to cater to more conversational queries. Instead of zeroing in on just 'vegan pasta recipes,' consider long-tail keywords like 'how to make creamy vegan pasta at home.'

The rise of visual search

Platforms like Pinterest and Google Lens allow users to search using images. Imagine taking a photo of a pair of shoes and immediately finding out where to buy them! This trend underscores the importance of optimizing visual content. Think alt texts, image descriptions, and relevant file names. And, while we're on the subject, ensure those images are high-quality and relevant. After all, a picture's worth a thousand words, right?

Video content continues to reign supreme

If you've not hopped onto the video bandwagon yet, now's the time! Platforms like YouTube and TikTok are dominating the scene. But remember our keyword lessons? They apply here too! Optimize video titles, descriptions, and tags to ensure they reach the right audience without cannibalizing your existing content.

AI and machine learning in SEO

Search engines are getting smarter. With advancements in AI and machine learning, they're better equipped to understand user intent and deliver precise results. What does this mean for us? It underscores the importance of creating holistic, in-depth content that genuinely addresses user needs. No more superficial fluff pieces or keyword stuffing. Authenticity and depth are the order of the day.

The continued importance of mobile optimization

With more people browsing on-the-go, ensuring your content is mobile-friendly isn't just nice-to-have; it's essential. From responsive designs to fast-loading pages, ensure your users have a seamless experience, regardless of the device they're on.

Embracing E.A.T in content

Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness (E.A.T) have become critical in the eyes of search engines. It's no longer just about the right keywords but about being a genuine authority in your niche. Regularly update your content, cite reliable sources, and showcase your expertise.

Final thoughts: Embracing change and continuous learning

As we wrap up this deep dive, one thing's clear: the world of CRO and SEO is ever-evolving. But instead of feeling overwhelmed, let's embrace the change. Continuous learning, adaptation, and a genuine commitment to providing value will always set you on the path to success.

Over to you!

What's been your biggest takeaway from our discussion? Any trends you're particularly excited about? Or maybe some challenges you're grappling with? Jump into the comments and share your thoughts. And, as always, if you need a guiding hand or a sounding board, I'm just a message away. Let's navigate the future of digital marketing together!

Similar Pages

© 2024 | All Rights Reserved | Built with 🤍 in Montreal